Nashville's Juggernaut Rolls Into BMO Field

Josh Sargent scored a hat-trick in a 4-4 thriller against Chicago Fire last weekend, and Toronto FC are unbeaten in six MLS outings. Sounds great, right? Here's the thing — four of those six results were draws, they sit 11th in the standings on 26 points with a goal difference of -6, and Wednesday night they host the most dominant team in Major League Soccer. Robin Fraser's side have been hanging on by their fingernails, and Nashville SC are not the team you want arriving when you're in that mood.

BJ Callaghan's Nashville SC are simply in a different universe this season. Fifty-three points from 23 matches, a goal difference of +30, and 10 points clear of Inter Miami at the top of the overall MLS standings — this is a side that has only lost twice all campaign, once to Chicago and once to Orlando. While the likes of Lionel Messi at Inter Miami (18 goals, 10 assists in 20 apps) and FC Dallas's Peter Musa (18 goals in 21) dominate the fantasy football headlines in the Western Conference, Sam Surridge has quietly notched 13 league goals for Nashville and earns a SAM rating of 6.8/10 that understates his overall influence on Callaghan's press-heavy system. Nashville's SAM leader this week is Jack Maher at 7.5/10, reflecting how deep the quality runs in that squad — even the defenders are ticking. The recent transfer addition of Zaid Yañez from New York City FC only adds further depth to a side that barely needs it.

Toronto's problems start before a ball is kicked on Wednesday. Walker Zimmerman and Djordje Mihailovic both pick up red card suspensions and are out — that's a first-choice centre-back and arguably the club's most creative midfielder (24 key passes, 5 assists in 12 apps this season) gone in one fell swoop. Add in injuries to J. Osorio, N. Gomis, D. Kerr, Matheus Pereira, N. Palacio, L. Stefanovic, and N. Dorsch, and you start to understand why this club had to bring in a new director of player health from England's Premier League mid-season. The training room has essentially been a revolving door all year. Andy Najar is also suspended for Nashville after picking up his fifth yellow of the season in their draw at New York City FC, but losing one full-back is a footnote compared to Toronto's crisis list. The injury situation in this MLS clash genuinely tips the scale before kick-off.

For Toronto, the burden falls heavily on Sargent — 7 goals in 16 apps, SAM rating 7.2/10, and currently the club's top scorer in league football this season. Deandre Sallói (6 goals, 5 assists across 23 appearances, SAM 6.8/10) gives them a goal threat from midfield, and Richie Laryea (SAM 6.8/10) will be vital on the right. Derrick Etienne is expected to come into the XI, which shows you both the opportunity and the squad-depth problem Fraser is managing simultaneously. Nashville's defensive solidity — Brian Schwake earning a SAM of 7.3/10 in goal, Jeisson Palacios at 7.3/10 in defence — makes them the toughest back-line in MLS to break down. Compare Nashville's average of 9.5 shots per match to Toronto's 9.67 conceded and the penalty picture writes itself for any fantasy football manager building their Matchweek 24 lineup.

Toronto will make this competitive — Fraser's men are tough to beat at BMO Field, the crowd will be electric, and Sargent in this form is a genuine handful for any defence in the league or in Serie A, bundesliga, or la liga for that matter. But Nashville are a team operating with the confidence of a side on a historic run, and they're not walking away from Canada empty-handed. Nashville SC win this 2-0, and the Supporters Shield conversation continues without a serious challenger in sight.

Clubs in this story

Inter